Skip to content
The Touch and GoThe Touch and Go
GAO Warned FAA's Rushed Air Traffic Control Overhaul Risked Disruptions Before Nationwide Outage

AI-generated illustration

Aviation Safety

GAO Warned FAA's Rushed Air Traffic Control Overhaul Risked Disruptions Before Nationwide Outage

Months before a router installation in Arkansas triggered the longest commercial ground stop since 9/11, government auditors and former FAA officials cautioned that the agency was moving too fast without a master schedule.

By The Touch & Go EditorialPublished Nov 20, 11:45 PM2 min read

The gist

A September GAO report warned the FAA's speed-first ATC upgrade lacked a master schedule for 11,000 projects, months before a router failure grounded flights.

Continuing coverage

All Faa →

Federal auditors and former aviation officials warned months ago that the FAA's accelerated push to replace aging air traffic control equipment could cause serious disruptions. Last week, a technology failure forced airlines to cancel thousands of flights and led the agency to order the longest ground stop of commercial aircraft since the September 11, 2001 attacks.

The FAA said it has still not determined why installing a single router in Arkansas produced a data overload large enough to halt traffic nationwide. Officials have pointed to the router work, carried out during an update, as the trigger for the event. The agency has not released a finding on how a change at one site spread across the system.

The outage followed a sustained push from the Transportation Department to compress the modernization timeline. The overhaul of the country's antiquated air traffic control system had been projected to take roughly 10 years. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said the department would finish by 2028, before the end of President Trump's second term. At an event at DOT headquarters in April, Duffy said the project would take only two and a half years.

In September, the Government Accountability Office issued a report saying the FAA was prioritizing speed at the risk of cost uncertainty and potential disruptions. The auditors wrote that the agency risked an inefficient schedule that could cause excessive disruptions to air traffic control operations, and that it was introducing additional risk in the interest of expediency. The report faulted the FAA for not using a master schedule to coordinate more than 11,000 individual upgrade projects across the country.

Kevin Walsh, the GAO official who authored the report, said in a video released by the watchdog that the FAA was working from a couple thousand separate schedules with no overarching plan to tie them together efficiently. The FAA responded that there were too many projects to coordinate in that way. The agency said it was developing an artificial intelligence tool to help manage the schedules, but that the tool was still in testing. The upgrades continued at a rapid pace while that work went on.

Industry experts said the structure of the air traffic system makes fast equipment swaps risky. The network is interconnected and cannot be taken offline, so replacing even a small component can set off problems far from the work site. They compared it to pulling a block from a Jenga tower.

Michael McCormick, a former vice president in the FAA's Air Traffic Organization, said new technology must not overwhelm the legacy systems it connects to, and that the work requires a well-planned strategy. McCormick said the system does need to be modernized and to use new technology, but that there has been a push to do it fast. He said this outage, like most outages, could likely have been avoided.

The Transportation Department has defended the accelerated schedule. It said slowing down would mean continuing to depend on failing legacy systems that have themselves caused flight delays and cancellations. President Trump has since commented publicly on the nationwide ground stop and called on Congress to provide more money for the effort.

Originally reported by Scripps News

Share

The Daily Touch & Go

The day's best aviation news in your inbox. Free, no spam.